Glee vs. High School Musical

  • By reComparison Contributor
  • comments 8
  • views9001

Difference between Glee and High School Musical

Glee and High School Musical have become two of the biggest television franchises in recent history––and they cater almost exclusively to the teen market. It is therefore hardly surprising that the two would invite frequent comparisons to one another, since aside from targeting the teen market, they are both obviously musicals. Nevertheless, the two shows have a number of clear differences that may miss the scrutiny of even their most avid viewers. Let's take a look at the more significant points of each.

Glee
High School Musical

The Look

One thing that is immediately apparent with both shows is that a lot of work and thought went into the planning of the set design and wardrobe in terms of trying to make it look as realistic as possible. The costumes of both shows already influence young fashion victims all over the world and the sets and locations are some of the most vibrant and striking ones around. That being said, High School Musical is seemingly attuned towards the tastes of the teen and pre-teen crowd, Glee seems geared more toward an older audience.

Musical Numbers

One of the most obvious differences between both shows is how Glee features musical numbers only in the context of performances and/or rehearsals. No singing or dancing goes on outside of the context of a realistic scenario, unlike in High School Musical when the characters often simply drop everything and launch into a song or dance number.

Content and Delivery

Here is where the divide between both shows gets even wider. While High School Musical is almost the typical Disney concoction of saccharine sweet moments interspersed with highly produced song-and-dance numbers, Glee seems to have an almost off-the-cuff feel to the proceedings. This is not meant to be a criticism on either approach, as the quirkier stylings of Glee is definitely a breath of fresh air. And Disney’s venerable-yet-undeniably-successful formula continues to draw in new fans every generation.

One other important distinction is how Glee approaches various subject matters. The writing is noticeably edgier and it is obviously intended for an older audience, although it still remains within the bounds of the PG13 classification. High School Musical for its part is obviously geared towards younger kids.

Summary

Glee

  • Characters seem genuine and share a close relationship with each other
  • Has a distinctive look to the set design, colors, and wardrobe
  • Has a more grown-up focus than High School Musical
  • Musical numbers are performed only during “rehearsals” and “performances” tied in with the script
  • Musical numbers are indicative of the thoughts and feelings of the characters
  • Edgier and more humorous approach, think Madonna spoof
  • Still within the bounds of PG-13

High School Musical

  • Characters seem to share on on-screen as well as off-screen chemistry
  • Distinctive look to the set and costumes as well
  • Definitely more upbeat and traditional approach typical of Disney productions
  • Musical numbers are interspersed throughout the story
  • Music numbers often relate to what the characters are thinking and feeling
  • Definitely PG-13

Which is the best high school musical show?
  • Glee
  • High School Musical
 
 

Discuss It: comments 8

High School Musical is a rosy-cheeked Clearasil commercial. Glee is pimples and warts with a little bit of athlete’s foot all rolled into one. Granted, I find the big clean houses and trouble-free world of High School Musical appealing—it reminds me of the Annette Funicello surf movies of the '50s. But Glee is more like my actual high school experience, chock full of character building and squeamishly uncomfortable moments. Nobody bursts into song in the cafeteria or on the basketball court.

  • Guest
  • Sophia Hale wrote on October 2016

Yes, you're so damn right

  • Guest
  • madison wrote on December 2010

glee is da best hahi school musical is the worst

  • Guest
  • Wendell wrote on July 2011

PORRA GLEE É UMA PORCARIA QE TA TENTANDO IMITAR O HSM MAIS NAUM É TAUM BEM PRODUZIDO QUANTO HSM E NUNCA VAI TOMAR O LUGAR DE HSM.

  • Guest
  • kelly makoy wrote on February 2012

vai se fude essas pessoas q ficam falando mal do glee hsm n tem nada a ver com glee o glee e super diferente eles fazem os nerds serem popular e o hsm so colocam gente de boa aparencia n fodeeeee!!!!!nao fala mal do meu glee

  • Guest
  • kelly makoy wrote on February 2012

glee e muuuito bom parem de falar mal dele vcs sao super super invejosos kkk

  • Guest
  • kelly makoy wrote on February 2012

hsm e bom mais glee e mto melhor

  • Guest
  • fghdfg wrote on March 2012

nagchaka tay performances ti glee ken makatitileng tay voices da

Post a Comment
  • Name*
  • Email*
  • Website (optional)
  • arrow You are commenting as a Guest
  • arrow Your email will not be public
  • arrow Login or Sign Up and post using your reComparison account
  • arrow Facebook Connect