Above Ground Pool vs. Fiberglass Pool vs. Concrete Pool

  • By reComparison Contributor
  • comments 3
  • views8479

Difference between Above Ground Pool, Fiberglass Pool and Concrete Pool

Swimming pools are used by sun lovers for fun and leisure. Popular especially during summer to beat the heat at home or on vacation when a dip in the pool is romanticized or accepted as a full force kid’s sport. Swimming is glorified in the Olympic Games and people everywhere become inspired to learn to swim for fitness or fun – young and old alike. Backyard pools are very popular. Choosing a pool is important as a major home investment. Aside from the sizes of the swimming pools, there are also several makes and models. Let’s look at the above ground pool, the fiberglass pool and the concrete pool.

Above Ground Pool
Concrete Pool

Composition

Above ground pools, as the name suggests, is a swimming pool constructed above the ground. This may seem to be unusual since most of us are used to seeing swimming pools that are installed below the ground. A reason for installing an above ground pool is that in some areas where the ground freezes in the winter and it is difficult to excavate. Also ground freezing can damage the pool structure as the ice expands and retreats. On the other hand, fiberglass pools are made of a very strong material which comes from fine glass fibers which are used as a reinforcing agent. Fiberglass pools can be constructed above ground or below the ground. Concrete pools on the other hand are made of rock compounds below the ground. This is the most common type of swimming pool.

Durability

Above ground swimming pools are the least durable when it comes to its resistance from natural phenomena. But because it is above the ground, you do not have to worry about ground freezing affecting your pool. Fiberglass pools are considered the most durable pools out there. Because they are made of durable glass, they can withstand any nature caused event like an earthquake or even ground freezing, whether the pool is installed underground or above the ground. Concrete swimming pools are not so good in ground frozen areas for they might get damaged. Also, earthquakes could literally destroy a concrete pool.

Maintenance

When it comes to maintaining your pool, the hardest one to maintain is the above ground pool. Why? Because above ground pools do not only need cleaning from inside the pool itself but also from the outside of the structure in order for them to be maintained and presentable. Fiberglass pools are very easy to clean and cheaper to maintain. All you have to do is to vacuum the dirt from below the pool and you’re done. The second most difficult to clean is the concrete pool for you have to scrub the molds that stick to it in order to maintain it.

Summary

  • Above ground pools are best for areas where the ground freezes and in places where it would be a real challenge to dig up the ground and place a pool inside.
  • Fiberglass pools are made from the most durable material, are easy to install and easy to clean. Drawbacks includes issues with the sand shifting below the pool, the pools must be filled with water at all times, and emptying the pool has to be done in properly.
  • Concrete pools are the most popular type of pool and the hardest to maintain due to their structure and materials.

Above Ground Pool and Fiberglass Pool and Concrete Pool Video

Which pool type is best in Northern states?
  • Above Ground Pool
  • Fiberglass Pool
  • Concrete Pool
 
 

Discuss It: comments 3

  • Guest
  • Robin wrote on May 2010

Many installers still backfill with whatever comes out, when they dig the hole. The best refinisher I have ever met is a man named Paul Pulver. He is a licensed swimming pool contractor. He has built,sold and installed fiberglass pools. Today he does nothing but travel the country refinishing fiberglass pools. Yes Marcus, he will probebly be busy for the rest of his life.

I agree with this post. The three different pools have a unique characteristics that fits depending on the owner. The presence of a diving board lets everyone know immediately that a deep water area exists, and that is where all diving should be conducted. Diving in shallow water, less than six feet deep can be dangerous. A diving board directs children and adults away from shallow areas that are unsafe for diving, keeping diving to the deep end of the pool, where diving is safe and fun.

  • Guest
  • Hayward Cleaner Parts wrote on April 2012

When we compare the three types of pools and their required maintenance, there really isn’t much difference between them, although if you don’t have a deck around your above ground pool that makes it much harder to get around and vacuum.

Post a Comment
  • Name*
  • Email*
  • Website (optional)
  • arrow You are commenting as a Guest
  • arrow Your email will not be public
  • arrow Login or Sign Up and post using your reComparison account
  • arrow Facebook Connect