Neosporin or Vaseline: Which one is used more often on minor scrapes?

  • Neosporin
  • Vaseline
Please select one to answer and see the result

Answers

Neosporin - 68Vaseline - 68
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Successful experiences since I was a kid. I'm 51 and still use it for myself, my kids and grandkids.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Designed as a medication.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
because of the three antibiotics it contains
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
It's basically vaseline with antibiotic properties.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
don't know ...seems to be used often
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Just because it says triple antibiotic and others dnt


  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
My mom's the one who introduced me to Neosporin, and I use it for almost every small skin injury, such as a paper cut, burn or scrape. I do notice that the wounds generally heal faster when I use Neosporin than with nothing, although I've never tried Vaseline for the same purpose.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
i have a gash in my toe freaking tell me which is better
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Most people believe they need an antibiotic to prevent infection.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Cause my mum said
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
E
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Heals way faster then vaseline
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Antibacterial
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Because
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
it heals well
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
God is dead
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
1
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
less messy
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
People think they got to have antibiotic. However, as we began to develop more and more resistant bacteria, years ago, I began recommending Vaseline instead of the antibacterials. However, that was with strict instructions to wash the wound with warm soap and water carefully first, not allow fingers in the Vaseline, and to apply it with Q-tips that haven't been exposed to touching either. I didn't notice any increase in my infections rates. I still use antibiotic creams in immunocompromised patients (diabetes, transplants, HIV, etc.), for wounds that already had the appearance of infection and for more severe/deep wounds. For minor cuts/scrapes, however, Vaseline is fine. In patients with infection already present, one study showed antibiotic to be about 3x more effective than Vaseline alone.The point of the Vaseline is to moisten the wound and provide a barrier to bacteria, not so much killing bacteria already there.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Because your article states is hastens the healing process with triple properties.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
That's what's in the medicine cabinet. It seals and protects
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
??
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Its used for that in ads

  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
antibiotic
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Because it has triple antibiotic ointment.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Neosporin because Vaseline doesn't have any agents to fight bacteria so instead Vaseline just traps it there . ^ . ).
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Vaseline only protects, Neosporin HEALS
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Antibiotic
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Pain relief also
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Neosporin is widely and aggressively marketed in the US. Folk remedies and 'alternative medicine' will always have their proponents, but too few people are willing to research the difference or don't think beyond knowing that neosporin is a relatively effective topical treatment.

The abstract at the end failed to assess relative effectiveness in those areas where both substances held the same effect. I was prompted to look up comparisons by a doctor stating they were roughly equivalent, despite the presence of the antibiotics in neosporin.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Small wounds and scrapes heal faster and the redness in my skin goes away faster than using nothing. Never new petrolium jelley was "ok" for open wounds.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
There is nothing in vaseline
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Prevents infection
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Possibly prevent infection
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
contains antibiotics
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
because idk
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
No one uses vaseline anymore for wounds, people expect that there is some sort of magical healing medicine in the ointment, and hence tend to use antibacterial ointments. Don't believe vaseline has been used in the modern home for scrapes and cuts in many decades, altho my mother always did. We didn't have anything else back then other than bactine, which was the preferred treatment.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
cuz
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Better marketing
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Because of the advertised benefits, but my plastic surgeon advises me to use Vaseline over areas he treated either skin movement or dermabrasion
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
It was used in my family for years, and works good so we stick with it :)
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
antibacterial
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
easy
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
BECAUSE WE ARE TOLD OVER AND OVER THAT IT IS BETTER, THAN VASELINE. AND OVER THE YEARS VASELINE IS NOT ADVERTISED, AS MUCH AS NEOSPORIN. EVEN THE MEDICAL COMMUNITY WILL RECOMMEND NEOSPORIN OVER VASELINE.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Advertizing
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
history
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
It work Miracles on ur Skin!!!!!
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Because it contains antibiotics
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Cause
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
In case of infection
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
SAMs wrong
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
because
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Common sense
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
It works.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
neosporin keep scrapes from getting infected.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Because Neosporin kills the bacteria in your wound, you won't end up with a nasty scar after it heals.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
namely the trio of antibiotics differentiates the two products & is a bonus in terms off infection control, otherwise I think they are made up of the same base material.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
because
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
i have never heard of using vaseline until today.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
It seems to work much better.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
until last week, i didn't even know what vaseline was used for ... :-)
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
It is what I have always used, keeps the wound moist and has antibiotics in case of an infection.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Prevented many a scrape or cut from infection, including the surgery infection in one of my spots on my back. I use it for everything from hang nails to any other break in my skin...it's fantstic!
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Antibiotic ingredients.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Neosporin has similar physical characteristics as Vasoline but adds antibiotics.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
first one
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
dunno really.
good marketing i guess, and i'm too lazy to do any research, and i've tried it before, and it does work.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
I like it
  • Anonymous . April 2022
Generic Vaseline can be cheaper than Neosporin or generic Neosporin.
  • Anonymous . January 2021
I've thought that during reading this people can use Neosporin and Vaseline/petroleum jelly so the Neosporin can kill bacteria THEN the Vaseline can seal the small wound and blocking the bacteria and healing the small wound faster
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
no infection
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
i use it
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Because it provides a sealing action that prevent bacteria from entering the
wound and keeping the surrounding area soft. Many people always have Vaseline
right at hand , for emergencies.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
It’s non allergic and is proven over many years to be as effective, or more effective than antibiotic ointments.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
common knowledge and experience with others
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
It help dryness and heal the scrapes
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Less scab formation. Neosporin can be an allergen
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Mainly because it was used as I was growing up for wounds, scars, mosquito bites and sunburn before going to bed. It is great for removing eye make up I still use it today.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
•Provides a sealing action that prevents bacteria from entering the wound
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Because my dermatologist recommends it versus Neosporin.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
cheap-just-as-good
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
i chose my answer based on the informationprovded before this question.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
because
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
I guessed
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Because people most often use what they have readily available
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
easy to use and less expensive
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
promotes healing and keeps bacteria from entering the wound
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
cuz dermatologist told me as well as post op surgery staff
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
because I have tried both and Vaseline works faster and the would healed scar free
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Older wel know ointment
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
It was recommended by dermatologist who removed small growth from my hand. I avoid antibiotics unless really needed.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Cheaper
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Recommended by dermatologist
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
I have a form of Lymphoma called Mycosis Fungoides which produces lesions of varying sizes and degrees on the skin. My cancer team told me to use Vaseline on the areas I scratched open. In April I had a basil cell cancer tumor surgically removed and was told to use only Vaselins.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
most effective
no allergic reaction (present with Neosporin)
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
More effective for wound care
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
sealing nature of vaseline
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Acts as a barrier preventing infection also keeps the area moist
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Vaseline is cheaper and you can use it on your lips
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Keeps it moist
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Recommended by doctor after after burning off a mole with nitrogen
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Because it is
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Every household has a jar of vaseline and it is inexpensive.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Most people have it in the bathroom-chemical free. AND, it can be used for a million other situations.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Recently a skin doctor asked me what I was putting on an open wound on my toe. I told him neosporin, he said I might as well use Vaseline.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
because vaseline is cheaper
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Longer history!
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
It is probably used MORE often because it is cheaper, has a wider usage, known for cold weather protection; and so if you considered chapping as a form of minor cuts then technically Vaseline will win as the most frequently used. However, if you ONLY count cuts where someone seeks help and is covering it with a band aid ... usage of Neosporin-like cream may out number Vaseline -- just because people think they will be making a difference.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
It seals cuts....
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
It feels like a more natural Choice.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
I
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
CHEAP
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
This is what I use and I am very smart.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Neosporin has.an antibiotic (neomianin) that many people ( about 11 percent) are allergic to.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Vaseline works great on cracked dry heals. The cracks heal quickly with no adverse allergic reaction as experienced with Neosporin.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Neosporin is no longer effective against bacteria as it once was, like a lot of antibiotics.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
It's been around forever, works and is inexpensive.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Recommended for safe healing by dermatologist after basil cell removal
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
It is soothing and seems to instantly doth the pain.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
My doctor recommends Vaseline and is against using Neosporin for wounds, etc., because it is an antibiotic which may produce side effects, and it is no better than Vaseline.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
oldie but goodie
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Preferred by my dermatologist
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Recommended for use by my dermatolist on surgically removal of squamous cell skin cancer on my head.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Readily available and inexpensive.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
heals my opem-n cuts and wounds faster...
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
i just know
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
I'm allergic to Bacitracin. Vaseline doesn't have it.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Because neosporin is marketing bullshit
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Because you only need to seal a scrape not treat it as an open wound.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
My dermatologist told me to use vasoline and NOT Neosporin
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
SAFER TO USE.
NO ADVERSE REACTIONS.
CHEAPER TO USE.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Provides a sealing action that prevents bacteria from entering the wound
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
I have treated sores that occurred after imiquimod treatment for basal cell cancers with vaseline. Great results in both speed of healing and prevention of scarring. This was recommended by my dermatologist and it really works. Also is soothing to the wound.


  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
A scrape is not really an open cut or wound.vaseline would seal out germs plus keep moisture in to promote healing.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Decreases the recovery period.

Related Questions

Related Comparisons