Carnatic Music or Hindustani Music: Which Indian music do you like best?

  • Carnatic Music
  • Hindustani Music
Please select one to answer and see the result

Answers

Carnatic Music - 17Hindustani Music - 13
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
i think there are more scales used in it...so there are much more possibilities... carnatic - jazz, hindustani - western classical...period
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Carnatic music is a Ocean and Hindustani music is like a river....
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
better melody more variation
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
It is orderly!
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
I LOVE CARNATIC MUSIC BECAUSE I AM TAMIL SO I UNDERSTAND MOST OF THE STUFF AND I ENJOY LEARNING CARNATIC MUSIC!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
don't know
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Carnatic is Ocean
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
It is more complex and hence appealing to me!!!.......LOL!...But I do like Hindustani Music too (perhaps equally. On monday I might like carnatic and on tuesday it could be hindustani.....cos I listen to both on a regular basis)
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
It has power in singing itself....hindustani will be light...gamakas will be like floating...
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
mas maganda pakinggan medyo matining lang
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Because it is unique and not like Hindustani. And to learn Carnatic music you should all south language and Sanskrit too without it you cannot perform Carnatic music. And moreover it all about based on our god not about some people are nature.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
No command....
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
I learned it and it seems to be more regal than hindustani
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
its just amazing dahling
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
I like Carnatic Music which has more understandable and singable tones.

Hindustani Music - all songs I mean movie songs sound same in most cases.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
I am a South Indian, and I am a orthodox person. While hindustani music is good, it is too emotional and unstructured for me
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
I enjoy a lot while listening CM rather than Hindustani.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
I love tabla , so obviously hindustani... but i like carnatic too :)
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
unlike carnatic music it is more aesthetical & the purpose of melody(raga) is aesthitics.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
I am a Hindustani vocalist!
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
CAN SING FREELY
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
it is more appelling to my ear,because of its swar based gayaki.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
it is more closer to the soul!
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Because I am learning hindustani music right now. I feel it's more melodious and it defines my life style.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
because it sounds better
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
Hindustani style appeals to heart,while Carnatic style appeals to head!
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
I am from Karnataka.Karnataka has produced great vocalists of Hindustani style,like pt.bhimsenjoshi,mallikarjun mansoor,gangubai Hangul.Kritis of Sri purandara Dasia is sung in both Hindustani &carnatic styles.Bhakti Bhava expressed in Hindustani style makes better impact on the mind than Carnatic.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
We need artists like smt:kaushiki desikan who is blending both styles very intelligently &bringing revolution in Indian music.
  • Anonymous . 3+ yrs. ago
i am north indian and never listen to carnatic.
  • Anonymous . December 2021
Firstly it's a versatile form of music and since my childhood I am learning this Hindustani classical music and I am very much attached with it.I enjoy this form of music a lot.

Related Questions

Related Comparisons